Markets open · Independent crypto analysis November 22, 2026
Markets

We Rebalanced a Crypto Portfolio Four Ways. The Spread Was 0.6 Points.

We ran the same eight-asset portfolio never rebalanced, then weekly, monthly and quarterly. The spread over a full year was 0.6 percentage points, before costs.

The CoinageReport Desk's avatar
The CoinageReport Desk
· 4 min read
X
A hand touching a digital trading chart, representing periodic portfolio rebalancing

Rebalancing means periodically selling whatever has grown past its target weight and buying whatever has fallen below it, so the portfolio keeps the shape you chose. It is sound discipline and it is not controversial. What is controversial is how much it is worth, so we measured it.

We took the eight largest non-stablecoin crypto assets we could price from one auditable source, started an equal-weight portfolio on 3 August 2025, and ran it forward on 366 daily closes to 3 August 2026.1 Then we ran the same portfolio four ways: never rebalanced, rebalanced weekly, monthly, and quarterly. Here is the whole result.

  • Never rebalanced — −52.0% — worst drawdown −67.1%
  • Rebalanced weekly — −52.4% — −67.9%
  • Rebalanced monthly — −52.4% — −67.9%
  • Rebalanced quarterly — −52.6% — −67.9%
  • For comparison, holding only Bitcoin — −44.2% — −53.2%

The spread between the best and worst rebalancing schedule was 0.6 percentage points over a full year. Before costs. Fifty-two rebalances across eight assets is 416 round trips, and at any realistic fee the weekly strategy finishes behind the strategy of doing nothing at all.

Our reading

Rebalancing is sold as a source of return — the “rebalancing bonus,” harvested by systematically selling strength and buying weakness. In a portfolio of assets that move together, there is no strength and weakness to arbitrage, and the bonus does not appear. That is what happened here. It is a discipline for controlling what you own, and it is worth doing for that reason. It is not a strategy for making money, and anyone presenting a rebalancing schedule as a way to improve returns should be asked to show the spread they measured.

The more uncomfortable line in the table is the last one. All four versions of the diversified portfolio lost more than simply holding Bitcoin, and each carried a drawdown roughly fifteen percentage points deeper. Spreading across eight assets did not reduce risk in this window. It increased it, and it cost eight percentage points of return to do so.

When it should matter

Rebalancing earns its keep when holdings diverge, and the eight assets here did not diverge enough. A portfolio split between crypto and something genuinely unrelated — the classic case — would produce a very different table, and nothing in this test argues against that. The claim we are testing is narrower and more common: that rebalancing within a crypto portfolio is a meaningful lever. Over this year, on these assets, it was worth less than a rounding error.

What this does not show

One window, one direction. This is a single 365-day period in which every asset fell, and rebalancing behaves differently in a market where leaders and laggards trade places. A rising or rotating market could plausibly produce a wider spread, and we have not tested one. Treat the 0.6-point figure as a result about this year, not a law.

The simulation charges no fees, no spread and no tax. All three penalise frequent rebalancing, so including them would widen the gap in favor of doing nothing, not narrow it. Equal weighting across eight assets is our choice, not a standard, and a market-cap-weighted version would sit much closer to the Bitcoin-only line simply because Bitcoin would dominate it. Daily closes hide everything that happened intraday.

We will re-run the identical simulation on 3 November 2026 and again after a quarter in which the market rises, because that is the test this result actually needs.

Sources
  1. DefiLlama, historical price chart API. Eight assets, daily period, 366 observations from 3 August 2025 to 3 August 2026. Pulled 3 August 2026. ↩

This article is for informational purposes only and is not financial advice.

Get the next report in your inbox

Weekly market notes and analysis. No noise.

TH
Written by
The CoinageReport Desk

An editorial byline, not a pen name. Pieces published under the Desk were researched, their figures independently re-checked against source, and reviewed before publication. Editorial responsibility rests with the Editor in Chief.